Personal Injury Attorney - New York City, Manhattan, Queens, Brooklyn, Bronx, NY
Your Injury
IS PERSONAL In all the ways it affects you. We can help.
Medical
Malpractice is a violation of trust. Your rights matter.
Airline
Accidents involve terrible losses. Turn to our expertise.

Delay and Defend: The Fatal Risks of Partial Medical Error Disclosure

We trust physicians to deliver prompt, effective care. Accurate diagnosis leads to accurate treatment. Clear communication leads to a stronger doctor-patient bond. There are expectations for the Hippocratic Oath to be upheld. Swift and direct care from a physician can prolong life, as is often the case with skilled medical professionals. However, sometimes our care quality falls short of our standards. Withholding information on and not admitting to medical errors can cut life short.

A survey by Georgia State University was given to more than 300 primary care physicians from a variety of healthcare systems, located in three different states. The hypothetical scenarios they were given took place in an oncology setting, involving two instances of delayed care. The first involved a delay in the diagnosis of breast cancer, while the second error was due to a slow response to patient symptoms attributed to a lack of communication in coordinating the patients’ care.

When asked if they would offer the patient full disclosure to answer why their care had been delayed, the results were troubling. Seventy-seven percent of PCPs in the first scenario, along with fifty-eight percent from the second stated that they would withhold information regarding the error, choosing to vaguely address the cause of the problem instead.

According to the study, “The majority of respondents (71 percent) had been in practice for more than 10 years, over half (55.6 percent) indicated they often questioned whether the demand of their practice was worth the toll, and a third (36.7 percent) often thought about leaving practice.” Patients deserve better. They deserve an upholding of the Hippocratic Oath physicians take-“do no harm” is a commandment, not an option.

Why withhold information?

When something goes wrong, you want to hear answers, not “it wasn’t my error.” Unfortunately, this mindset is all too prevalent among providers. When those words are spoken, patients hear nothing but denial. This statement is attached to the “deny and defend” policy that many hospitals still use. This method denies the patient full disclosure regarding medical practice (including errors) and keeps them in the dark.

Too often, medical errors lead to adverse events. These are serious, unanticipated outcomes which are usually non-fatal, but can still be devastating. The silence surrounding the disclosure of adverse events only serves to deepen the emotional (and, if further complications arise, financial) wounds that leave lives in disarray and break the much needed bond of trust between patient and provider.

Why is a patient left out? Some common reasons include:

  • Fear of embarrassing oneself or a coworker
  • Lack of a “just culture” in which reporting events is encouraged without worry
  • Physician stress
  • Lack of trust and communication in a weak or non-existent patient-doctor bond

An article from the New England Journal of Medicine states: “Multiple barriers, including embarrassment, lack of confidence in one’s disclosure skills, and mixed messages from institution and malpractice insurers make talking with patients about errors challenging.” Medicinal culture lacks a reward system for reporting errors. It also fails to facilitate proper coordination of care between providers and discussion about care errors. The same article also notes that “fear of how a colleague will react, along with strong cultural norms around loyalty, solidarity, and ‘tattling’ may deter such conversations.”

But failure to disclose medical details and errors has claimed more than one life, and will continue to take more if action isn’t taken.

The Boston Globe covered one such case from 2013. A young woman delivered premature twins via C-section. Everything seemed to be OK. But a week later, one of the children was treated for a deadly intestinal condition known as necrotizing enterocolitis. Her blood had turned acidic, and surgeons removed her colon in a last-ditch effort to save her life. The baby died, just 8 days old. Sadly, this fatality could have been avoided had clinicians paid attention to early symptoms of the condition.

In another case, a teacher’s breast cancer diagnosis was completely missed and the lump in her breast was deemed “fine.”  But the only “fine” in her case involved legal fees and, thankfully, financial compensation. Stress from her case was also alleviated via a face-to-face meeting with her doctors, proving that steps can be taken towards repairing and re-instituting a doctor-patient bond with full disclosure instead of darting around the issue.

What can be done to change the situation?

We count on our healthcare system to help us, not work against us by withholding information. Where there are unreported errors, there were preventable measures not taken. Only ten states make it mandatory for errors to be disclosed to patients, and none of that even guarantees an apology.

Steps can be taken to reduce the number of occurrences, by both providers and medical institutions. They can work to re-implement a culture that promotes the reporting of errors both to higher authorities and patients. Patient-centered care includes the necessity for apology and explanation, as well as working towards preventing another error.

Adept in handling medical malpractice cases and providing an individualized approach to every case, the Jonathan C. Reiter Law Firm, PLLC can help victims of undisclosed errors find their voices again.

Medical non-disclosure can often result in debilitating, sometimes fatal, outcomes. For the sufferers of provider failures, contacting Attorney Jonathan C. Reiter is the first step towards recovery and well-deserved compensation. A free case evaluation is the opportunity that innocent victims need to speak up, take initiative, and commence seeking compensation.

Jonathan C. Reiter's

New York City Personal Injury Lawyer / Aviation Accident Attorney

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

Lenox Hill Hospital

A 652-bed teaching hospital, Lenox Hill Hospital is located in the Lenox Hill neighborhood at 100 E. 77th Street. This 652-bed on the Upper East Side of Manhattan serves mostly patients from Manhattan, but other patients are admitted from Brooklyn, Bronx, Queens, Long Island and throughout the tri-state region. Anyone who suspects negligence after treatment should speak with an experienced attorney immediately.

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

Bellevue Hospital Center

Bellevue Hospital Center at 462 1st Avenue has 828 beds and experiences 115,797 emergency room visits each year. Bellevue had a higher rate of infections compared to hospitals in other states, according to a New York State Department of Health Report in 2009. Anyone who is injured by the negligence of a doctor or nurse at this Manhattan hospital, the oldest in the United States, will need an experienced attorney with experience and resources needed to take aggressive action.

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

New York Presbyterian-Lower Manhattan Hospital

Lower Manhattan Hospital at 170 William Street in New York is one of the main campuses of New York-Presbyterian Hospital. This hospital, with 170 beds, provides a range of inpatient and outpatient services. According to an article in the New York Post, New York-Presbyterian scored 18 percent below average for patient safety in a ranking of hospitals by Consumer Reports magazine. Patients who suspect medical malpractice should not hesitate to arrange a consultation with a New York City attorney who can investigate and hold the negligent medical care provider accountable.

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

Mount Sinai Beth Israel

The main hospital known as the Petrie Division is located at First Avenue and 16th Street. But Mount Sinai Beth Israel has other campuses, including Phillips Ambulatory Care Center at Union Square. Mount Sinai Beth Israel is a teaching hospital with 1,368 beds. If you suffered any form of negligence while being treated at Mount Sinai Beth Israel, take action immediately to protect your rights.

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center

Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center at 1275 York Avenue in Manhattan provides cancer care to patients. The hospital is composed of two institutions: Memorial Hospital for Cancer and Allied Diseases, which provides patient care, and the Sloan Kettering Institute, which is focused on research. Patients who suspect a failure to diagnose cancer or some other type of hospital negligence can contact a lawyer to discuss options.

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

Mount Sinai Hospital

Mount Sinai Hospital at One Gustave L. Levy Place is a 1,048-bed facility founded in 1852. It is one of the oldest and largest teaching hospitals in the country. Consumer Reports rated Mount Sinai 31 percent below average for patient safety. If you or a loved one was a victim of medical malpractice at any Manhattan hospital, don’t wait to contact an attorney to find out if you have a case. You may be entitled to compensation.

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

St. Luke’s-Roosevelt Hospital Center

St. Luke’s Roosevelt Hospital Center at 1111 Amsterdam Avenue was ranked No. 14 out of the 30 worst hospitals for patient safety, as identified by Consumer Reports. The magazine examined four key measures of patient safety: hospital-acquired infections, readmissions and the quality of communication between staff and patients in regard to medications and discharge planning.

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

New York-Presbyterian/ Columbia University Medical Center

New York-Presbyterian/Columbia University Medical Center at 630 West 168th Street was described by a lawmaker as having “horrendous conditions.” Emergency room wait times last an average of 85 minutes, which rank among New York’s 10 worst. Any patient who was treated at the 995-bed hospital in Washington Heights and suspects negligence should not hesitate to speak with an attorney for a free consultation.

FREE CASE CONSULTATION

Manhattan Medical Malpractice Info Center

Harlem Hospital Center

Harlem Hospital Center at 506 Malcolm X Blvd. received a 20 on a 1-to-100 scale gauging patient safety by Consumer Reports. The hospital received the second worst score in the nation, according to a New York Post report. Harlem Hospital told Consumer Reports it needs to improve in some areas, according to the Post. The hospital is a general medical and surgical hospital with 272 beds.